Most Asbestos Diseases Linked to Mine Workers

April 09, 2000

Erica Curless, Missoulian State Bureau.

Direct exposure

HELENA - Most Libby residents with asbestos-related diseases had a direct connection to the former vermiculite mine or its workers, the federal Environmental Protection Agency has concluded.

This informal finding backs the agency's original guess about how residents were exposed to the deadly asbestos fibers that have allegedly killed 192 miners and family members and made another 375 ill. It also confirms that it's unlikely people are getting sick from just living in the area, home to the W.R. Grace and Co. vermiculite mine until 1990.

"What it means anecdotally is most of the cases we have out there are occupationally related or related to family exposure," said EPA on-scene coordinator Paul Peronard. "Yeah, we knew that, but this is how we know that this supports that hypothesis."

A representative from the Maryland-based mining company said the EPA findings speak for themselves.

"Paul's comments stand on their own," said Bill Corcoran, Grace vice president of public and regulatory affairs.

The EPA reviewed about 200 cases of Libby residents who have asbestos-related diseases such as asbestosis, lung cancer and mesothelioma.

Peronard reiterated that this study was informal and didn't carefully scrutinize all the clinical evidence or include all known cases of asbestos-related illness in the community.

It consisted of interviewing three doctors, who have treated the majority of asbestos exposures in the area, about the patients' history - other medical problems, whether they worked at the mine or if they played in the vermiculite piles.

Only two of the 200 reviewed cases were not related to some sort of direct exposure to asbestos or asbestos-contaminated vermiculite, Peronard said.

It's possible the doctors didn't have a complete history on these patients or that they may have gotten exposed to asbestos by just living in the town, he added.

This uncertainty is why the EPA continues to sample the area, looking for hot spots of contamination.

Peronard reiterates that more testing is needed and that the upcoming medical screenings are the only way to find factual answers.

"That's going to be the true indication of what the medical problems are going to be," Peronard said.

But it's likely most of the contamination is linked directly to the former mine, he said.

These preliminary conclusions show that 85 percent to 90 percent of the people included in those 200 cases worked at the mine.

When miners dug the earth for vermiculite ore they also stirred up asbestos, a mineral that naturally occurs in the Kootenai Valley. Asbestos is harmful to humans when inhaled because the needle-like fibers stick in the lung's lining and eventually cause disease. The damage is irreversible. Vermiculite itself is harmless.

In addition, of those 200 cases, 27 patients had family members who worked at the mine. Miners often tracked the asbestos dust into their homes on their work clothes, contaminating their families.

Six people didn't have an occupational link to the mine but did have direct contact with the exfoliated vermiculite. Many children, including Gov. Marc Racicot, played in vermiculite piles that dotted the town.

Although Grace tried to remove impurities, such as asbestos, from the vermiculite, it wasn't 100 percent successful. The EPA is still unclear how much asbestos is contained in vermiculite products, such as the housing insulation known as Zonolite found in thousands of home in Montana and across America.

The agency urges people to treat it like a hazardous material and leave it alone.

"So the big picture is no matter what we see now, most of these exposures had to be from working in the mine or living with someone who did," Peronard said. "The next big exposure was you had to have direct contact (with vermiculite)."

The federal Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry will begin medical screenings, which include chest x-rays and pulmonary function tests, in May. Officials anticipate testing up to 5,000 former and current Libby residents.